Runnymede Blog
Tottenham - a tragedy we should have seen coming?
Posted by Vicki 08 August 2011 : criminal justice , financial inclusion , BME ,
Today's blog post is written by our director, Dr Rob Berkeley
The scenes beamed around the world of Tottenham in flames are a tragedy. A tragedy for the already vulnerable people of Tottenham whose lives and livelihoods have been put at unnecessary risk, a tragedy for a city that had begun to imagine itself as an exemplar of good relations between people from different backgrounds, but also a tragedy for our politics that creates the situation in which street disturbances of this kind can happen.
The image of the hooded youth aiming a missile at police lines against a backdrop of burning vehicles is too reminiscent of the riots of thirty years ago to be ignored. We may have told ourselves that those days could never return, but we have simply failed to examine the evidence. There is no excuse for rioting, but it is crucial that we understand the context in which it happens.
In 1981 we could look at the disenfranchisement and despair among large sections of London youth. In education there was a 20 point-gap in achievement between Black and White youth. In Haringey schools this year that gap had increased to one of 35 points.
In 1981 we could highlight the levels of youth unemployment - which reached as high as 45%. Currently 20% of White young people are unemployed, 40% of Pakistani youth and half of all Black youth.
In 1981 we noted poor relationships between the police and young people with the now infamous 'sus' laws. Reports earlier this year highlighted that Black men were 8 times more likely to be stopped and searched than white men. Under some powers such as Section 60 this rises to 26 times more likely. Effective policing would clearly be welcomed by a community such as that in Tottenham where people are much more likely to be victims of crime. Effective policing is based on trust and consent, rather than antagonism and suspicion.
It appears that we have failed to learn from the past and are therefore doomed to repeat our mistakes. Mistrust of the police has once again been the spark in a tinderbox of exclusion and hopelessness that creates the conditions for riots of this type. Despite the efforts of many people in communities to advocate for change and to address the exclusion of young people, from the Peace Alliance to Haringey Young People Empowered, they are not helped by the overwhelming inequality faced by those they are working with.
As Tottenham picks itself up and its people seek to restore their lives, we look forward to hearing from government what they intend to do to help. This week in New York we have seen Mayor Bloomberg announce a $1 billion public/private partnership to address the economic exclusion of African American and Latino young men. In London, an initiative of this kind seems to be too much to ask. Instead we have a government that is yet to publish a strategy to address racial inequality, 75% cuts to youth services in Haringey, a policing strategy that is failing to address the serious youth violence on our streets, and the organisations that might make a difference scrabbling for resources rather than being able to address the problems.
Just as evidence tells us what conditions drive riots, it can also tell us what works in minimising them. Government and civil society both have roles in finding the solutions. If we know that racial inequality creates bad outcomes for us all, why is so little being done to address it? The people of Tottenham deserve answers.
For press inquiries, contact Vicki Butler: 020 7377 9222 or email our of hours v.a.e.butler[at]googlemail[dot]com Â
The Runnymede Blog
The Runnymede Blog is a space for us to explore issues relevant to race and ethnicity.
We also seek to provide updates of race equality-related issues within the Westminster village.
The blog is often written by Runnymede's public affairs manager Vicki Butler, and also by other members of the Runnymede staff team or external contributors, where stated.
Subscribe
If you’d like to subscribe to our weekly blog e-update please email Vicki Butler
Recent Blog Posts
- Assimilation 1 Racial Justice 0
- Racist murders in Europe: rising xenophobia and the role of the far-right
- How far right will Sarkozy go to remain in power?
- A criminal’s charter? Defending the Human Rights Act, again
- Raising the income tax threshold is not the best way to improve the lives of the worst off
Editor's Pick
- Justice for Stephen Lawrence ‘not a cause for celebration’ but a call to action
- True multiculturalism acts as a bulwark against further extremism
- Trevor Phillips argues equality is key to economic recovery
- Lord Parekh highlights impact of spending cuts on ethnic minorities
- Why financial inclusion matters
- Conservative party conference: Big society and localism top of the agenda
- Race equality and the emergency budget
- The impact of the Queen's Speech on race equality
- The Budget and BME Communities
- Government Gypsy and Traveller policy under fire
- Equality Bill Report Stage
Tag Cloud
Blogroll
- Operation Black Vote
- Racialicious
- Refugee Council Blog
- 2020 Public Services Trust
- Platform 10
- Demos
- ippr Election Blog
- Liberal Conspiracy
- UK Polling Report
- Iain Dale's Diary
- Conservative Home
- Labour List
- Left Foot Forward
- Liberal Democrat Voice
- Lucinda Neall
- CentreForum blog
- Next Left
- Politicana
- RSA - Matthew Taylor
- The Samosa
- Spectator Coffeehouse
- ResPublica Blog
- Joseph Rowntree Foundation
- TUC
Blog Archive
- February 2012 - (3)
- January 2012 - (5)
- December 2011 - (1)
- August 2011 - (4)
- May 2011 - (1)
- April 2011 - (2)
- March 2011 - (5)
- February 2011 - (6)
- January 2011 - (2)
- December 2010 - (9)
- November 2010 - (9)
- October 2010 - (6)
- September 2010 - (10)
- August 2010 - (9)
- July 2010 - (10)
- June 2010 - (14)
- May 2010 - (10)
- April 2010 - (27)
- March 2010 - (19)
